Robie,
My two cents on a new hunting coat would be to go with one of the best...Forget the camo that is marketing hype...My grandfather shot many of waterfowl in his lifetime using an old "lumber jack" with the hat to match...A Filson 400 or 600 series cotton waxed field coat and buy the hood for it...I believe the new number system is an actual 10091 or something of that nature...In green or tan...I have the tan version...Either way the coat is simple...No zippers just buttons...I have had a wonderful three seasons without rewaxing the coat...I have hunted almost 40 days each season from 60 degree rainy downpours early season Michigan, Grouse hunting thickets around Claire, MI, 5 degree February conservation goose seasons around Fort Wayne, Indiana, diver hunting Kentucky on my back in an MLB, to timber hunting wet Louisiana late season without a worry...My Columbia jacket after three seasons of hunting wore the gore tex out and had to be replaced, a Drake shell I bought to hunt with ripped on my third hunt...Outside of hunting I have also used it to work in around the yard, cutting wood, and etc...It is made out of what they call shelter cloth and it does keep you sheltered...To clean the jacket take a wet sponge if the mud is fresh or when dried, a few strikes with a large brush and the jacket is clean again...After season this year I put it in the shower and gave it a good cleaning and let it hang up to dry...After about 3 to 5 years of heavy use a small can of wax will re-seal the abuse ...The older the coat becomes the better it gets...Mine is actually getting into a dark phase where I have used it so much...A natural camo appeal...
If your prefer the Tin coth series has zippers which allow you zip in different weight wool liners...You can not beat the coat for the value...
For the $250 to $300 you rake out there I believe you will have a coat for a life time...I have met a few hunting buddies here in Louisiana whom bought them for this season because of the coats ability to take the abuse...
Now the coat is your best bet for outside protection...A wool liner or sweater works even better...Late season I recommend a Wool Wind shear sweater underneath...Can't be it! There are not too many things that can beat it...
The caveat is weight...They are slightly heavier coats...
Regards,
Kristan