A lot of ways you can go. Out of curiosity what was the old one made from? Do you plan to glass with epoxy? What options do you have in your area? Maybe not a fit for your needs but two layers of 3/4" plywood epoxied together and then cut to shape, smoothed and rounded, and then glassed with epoxy has served me well on several boats. Or do you want to stick with dimensional wood for historical reasons?
Eric