Well then you really don't want to hear from me...especially because all I have to add woud be get a pump...no one complains of pumps not cycling, and if they do, it is usually user error...oh wait, I shouldn't have posted all that, I'm changing the subject...
PS, I don't use emoticons, so if you don't get my humor, disregard the above comments[/QUOTE]
I have shot a pump for the last 30 years, my Remington 870 is an outstanding gun which performs admirably in almost any waterfowling situation except one.... shooting out of my duckboat, let me elaborate.
When shooting out of my duckboat, I am sitting on the floor and thus can only turn my body to swing on birds from the waist up. I am a right handed shooter and while I arrange my decoys so that birds land in my sweet spot (about 45 degrees to the left of my direct front), they occasionally land or fly elsewhere. My biggest problem with the 870 pump has been when birds come across my spread from the left, to the right. I can always get the first shot off, but being right handed shooter as I swing to the right it gets hard to fully pump the 870 as my left arm is no longer capable of fully extending. This has led to several missed birds last year, including a banded black duck on the last day of the season. Last year was a tough duck year and I vowed not to come up short if that shot presented itself again. That being said, while the 870 pump is a great gun, an autoloader has an advantage when swinging to the right out of a duckboat because you do not have to pump!
So, no... there is no "user error" here, it's just a liability of a pump in this particular situation.