Grew up using a mid 70's vintage 6hp Johnson on a 12' Mirrocraft alum. boat, did great. That said, I had a 2stroke 5hp Mercury that would probably do great on your boat, very light motor and also has an onboard tank so you don't have to carry a gas tank, although sometimes the counterweight of 6gal. of gas up in the bow is nice. I don't think you'll be happy with anything smaller than a 4hp, especially if you have any type of load, even two adults, a few decoys and gear. Just my 2 cents, good luck with your search.