My experience in the outdoors has led me to have a healthy respect for mother nature... I have seen a flat calm body of water go to 3-4 foot chop in less than 20 minutes when an unexpected squall hit. I have also seen the most prepared & experienced people run into problems on the water when weather comes up... unexpected things can happen, remember Murphy's Law?
No disrespect to Matt, I have met him and he is a nice guy and I am by no means saying his boat is not sea-worthy, I saw it and loved it to be honest. But when on the water, especially in the winter months I like to err on the side of caution... way on the side of caution.
Once while duckhunting many years ago, my buddy and I found an unlucky winter cod fishermans boat run aground... the boat was in gear, out of gas and there were still rods & fish in the boat. That fisherman was never found and it was a calm day. To this day that gives me chills, it was like a ghost boat and that guy was experienced on the water.
After that I vowed to always be prepared, err on the side of caution and to do my best to come home to my family when hunting of fishing. I now wear harnesses in my treestand, inflatable PFD's in the boat, have all my life-saving gear, carry a VHF and cell phone and always tell my family where I am going. I really want to come home to them after a fun hunt.
I'm not saying that all that stuff will save my life, but it sure gives me a better chance. That being said, I am sure Matt has some foam somewhere else in his boat as well as all the necessary PFD's. He seems like a good hunter and a smart guy...