Duckworthy? Seaworthy?

Ben M

Active member
So, I've bought the plans for my first boat: a sneakbox. And for Christmas, I loaded up on a lot of the necessary tools. The bug has bitten hard! I'm already planning my next build . . . assuming of course, this first one doesn't drive me to the brink of sanity and/or wreck my marriage! Hahaha . . .

I'd appreciate your opinions about this particular design:
http://www.bateau.com/proddetail.php?prod=XF20

I would mainly hunt skinny inshore spots with it, with 2 or 3 trips a year out to the Chesapeake or other bigger water. I want something that will 1) Allow me to take 2 or 3 other hunters plus a dog & dekes and not be in each other's laps and, 2) Be reasonably seaworthy for bigger water while maintaining a low profile and shallow draft, and 3) Allow my growing family and maybe a few friends to comfortably hang out and/or fish lakes. Last year, on a buddy's V-hull we finally found a concentration of ducks late in the day and set up to hunt them, but the tide was on the way out and we were many miles from home. He was afraid of being grounded, so we pulled up and headed in. With a shallower draft, flat bottom hull like this one, we could have stayed for a couple hours more.

I would want to add some decking/coaming round the edges in typical duck boat fashion, and probably a spray dodger/blind that could also be used to keep my wife & family dry on summertime lake runs. The extra decking & spray dodger would contribute to this boat's seaworthiness. And I'm pretty sure it's self-bailing (or can be made so) which means a nasty roller would certainly scare the living hell out of you . . . right before it swept on out of the bailers. I would definitely go with tiller-steer to keep a console from adding height to the hull.

I'm concerned that it may be a bit big for littler spots . . . and that it might not be seaworthy enough for bigger water. Which means, I might have a good compromise! Hahaha . . .
 
Looks like a nice skinny water boat but I would want more gunwale for duck hunting big open water.
 
If you are looking for a 20' boat... look at the Devlin Honker. You can simply extend the boat in the middle to what ever length you want. That is what I did. After scarfing 10' sheets you can come up with a boat that is 19"3" or 19'4" that is what mine is, and I had no scrap left over. LITERALLY.. it drafts about 10" and has been on moderate seas on Lake Michigan without concern.... I did a few other mods... but...
 
Yes, it is indeed a flats boat. But I'm wondering how it might work out as a Chesapeake Bay-type-water boat. Not open ocean stuff with 8ft swells. I've spent a lot of time on the ocean, and in smaller bays, but I'm not intimately familiar with the many faces of the Chesapeake.

I like the low profile & bigger size for bigger water & the ultra-shallow draft for skinny stuff. Sounds like yall wouldn't want to hunt it at all in bigger water?

How do you think it would do in a 3-4ft chop? 5ft max. Much bigger than that & being on the water starts to lose a lot of the fun factor for me, even in a bigger, V-hull boat...
 
Have you looked at the Honker? The deck looks very similar....

I am sure with the right captain, that boat would handle 3-5' seas.... Would I build that boat with the expectation of using it in 3-5' seas.. or the Chesapeake???? Never....
 
Last edited:
Ben,

I have eyed that plan for an airboat..with a few mods and a covering of high density polymer on the bottom of the hull. The boat would replace an older airboat I have that is used on the Great Salt Lake on occasion. The water is 1-12 inches deep for the most part. I agree with the folks opposed to the design to be used on larger, deep, open water.

Do you need two boats? Plenty of building to get after.

Matt
 
Back
Top