Near Tragedy on the PendOreille River -- Long read

Gary March

Well-known member

It was December 14th 2007, I had my truck loaded with gear and the Barnegat in tow. I was headed to my favorite place, Ruby Creek Lodge on the PendOreille River in the northeast corner of Washington State. I was full of
anticipation, knowing well that the middle of December marked the time when the migration of Redheads, Bluebills and Canvasbacks showed in great numbers. I arrived at the lodge late and tired that evening. It was a very long week at
work and was looking forward to a weekend with just myself and my Water Spaniel (River) enjoying the next two days in the marsh. I had been going to the lodge for the past 5 years and was greeted by the owners, Jason and Chrisee as
though I was family. I stay at the lodge every weekend for the entire 105 day season with the exception of a few other hunts elsewhere. I poured my usual glass of scotch, and sat around the fireplace catching up on Jason’s hunts prior
to me arriving. After making a large lunch for myself and River it was time for me to get some needed rest. River had already gone to bed knowing she was in for a long cold day. I awoke to the sound of the alarm going off, and found
myself moving like a 54 year old that had been doing this for 40 years. My spirit was full of anticipation at what first light would bring, but my body didn’t seem to agree. After eating my favorite old fashioned donuts and drinking a
cup of coffee it was time to drive the short five miles to the boat launch. While driving, I remember thanking God for giving me so many days in the marsh. It seems to be the only place that rejuvenates my soul. While pulling into the
launch I felt it would be wise to chain up the truck. Nothing will wake you up faster than laying on the snowy ground in the dark putting on cold chains.
Following my gps plotter trail, I worked my way upriver in the snowy darkness. River, as usual was up on the bow with a heart full of excitement, anticipating our arrival. I labored over which blind to hunt, and finally decided
to set up on a downriver point on an island. My set of decoys this day was mostly canvasbacks, redheads and two dozen half shell goose decoys. The bay on my left was completely frozen over as it was 14 degrees when I left the lodge.
The main river channel on my right was open and flowing with a light current.
First light came and there was a stillness in the air that took me by surprise. Not many birds trading on the river. The snow was falling hard and I assumed the birds would move later as the storm subsided. After sitting in the
blind for about two hours it was time to dunk the decoys of all the fallen snow. The few birds that did work our set flared on the final approach. Finally I looked upstream scanning the river and saw a large flock of about 60 redheads
trading downriver towards my blind. As they made there first pass, I called on my 1940s Zimmerman broadbill call. They liked what they saw and heard and aggressively banked, turned into the wind for there finale approach. My side by
side barked twice and to my astonishment there were two drakes lying still in the decoys. River was doing her best to get both of them in one pass. She finally gave in and delivered one to my hand , then went back for the other. She
then gave me that look like “This is what we came for”. As I was putting the birds on my leather strap I heard in the distance a faint call of a goose from behind us. Rivers ears were high on her head trying desperately to locate the
goose. I made a quick call on my flute then I looked to my right, there was a single locked up and coming into my decoys. This time I missed on my first shot but folded the large goose on the second. River was very aggressive as
always when it comes to retrieving geese. I think she is reminded of the very first goose she retrieved. We were on an island and the goose I knocked down was very much alive. She was ten months old and that goose beat her with its
wings profusely. From that day forward even a call on my flute gets her wired.
Little did I know as the next turn of events unraveled, I would be on my knees praying for my life. Again I heard a distant call from a goose. This time River was locked on it with both eyes. The bird was coming into the decoys
as though it was on a suicide mission. I stood up, shot and folded the goose with one shot. It feel to my left and landed on the ice in the bay. River bolted out of the blind and ran out on the ice. I called for her to stop and she
ignored my command. She had been whistle trained to stop on command, But by the time I found my whistle on my lanyard she had fallen through the ice about 5 yards in front of the goose. My Barnegat was about 300 yards upstream from me
on the island point. I ask myself “what can I do“? She was hanging onto the ice by her front paws, as the current was trying to pull her under the ice. She was crying profusely like no cry I have ever heard. I knew she would be gone
by the time I went to get my boat and come back. There was a rotten spot in the ice where she went through. I couldn’t see another dark spot like that between me and her. I had no rope in my blind and my life jacket was in my boat. I
remember kneeling and saying a quick prayer. I had no options. I took my heavy parka off, laid on the ice and started crawling towards her. I wasn’t sure if she could last as her shrill voice was getting softer. I knew that if the
ice gave way to me I wouldn’t be coming home. I felt as though there were no other options. Slowly I kept calling her name and crawling towards her, asking myself “What are you doing? You idiot” Your life isn’t worth your dogs. All I
was thinking about was the long ride home without my hunting partner. As I kept moving forward my pace slowed as I knew it wasn’t the right thing to do. I was sick to my stomach, cold, wet and scared. I finally reached for her and
grabbed her front paw. At that time she slipped back into the water as saying “I have had enough.” I pulled as hard as I could and the ice kept breaking towards me. I backed up and pulled again and this time she slid up onto the ice.
She laid there wet and exhausted with no life left in her. I kept sliding backwards while reaching for her and pulling her towards me. I finally made it to shore, ran to the blind, wrapped her into a wool blanket. Rubbing her until
she got warmed up. We then went running up the island to warm her more. By now she was acting like nothing ever happened.
I have primarily hunted alone all my life, and have been told numerous times that it is a mistake. Especially when things go wrong. I have been blessed on a few different occasions and always seem to make it home. With the
exception of a hunt or two a year, I’m not willing to share my blind with anyone but my best friend, River! My American Water Spaniel. The passion to waterfowl hunt is so deeply imbedded in me, that I have never found anyone that likes
the sport as much as I do.

By Gary March

img4940gn9.jpg

img4986qn9.jpg

img4918td3.jpg

 
gary, great story and im glad everything worked out. your passion for the sport and love of your dog is very clear. best, mark
 
Oh Lord! What a close call! I don't know what I would have done if I was placed in a similar position... you have an angel on your shoulder watching out for you. Do you think you could have brought something with you to have made it easier to rescue River?
 
This story was just as good this time as the first time I read it. I know you love to hunt alone and so I say a prayer for you at the beginning of each season.
 
Gary...that's an amazing story. Next time I have a Scotch I'll toast the both of you. I can't say I'd have done anything different.
 
Glad it all worked out ok. Indeed an Angel was on your shoulder looking out for you and River.
 
I nearly posted a story the other day with about the same kind of situation. A guy hunting geese on the missouri river here in SD had his dog get in a bad situation. He was completely unprepared and went in to help his dog. Well the dog got out and he couldn't. His hunting partner couldn't get him out alone but lucky for him another pair of hunters happened alone and were able to get him out. He was very lucky.

I'm glad everything worked out for you back then and I think it is a good idea for hunters to think about what they would do in that situation and how to properly prepare before it happens. I know what I'd do and if most people would honestly talk to their families the decision would be much easier to make.

Tim
 
I'm reading this thinking .....man that's not a smart thing to do but my next thought is well.....I'd end up doing the same thing too.
 
Last edited:
Gary,

I recall this story well from when you posted it after the incident. I really contemplated what I would have done in that situation. I´m glad it all worked out for you and you´re here to tell your story. Be careful out there.

Ryan
 
Gary,not a long read at all but a very sobering one! Some day if we meet you will have then met a person who actually loves waterfowling more than you. I know, that is not possible----right!
Al
 
Gary - Thanks for posting this. I hunt alone a lot and it gives me some ideas - about rope. Being without a dog at this time, it also reminds me of how much I miss having a gunning partner. When I was in high school I fell thru the ice by myself on a 5 degree day. I somehow managed to shimmy up on one side of the hole and then use my feet to push off of the back of the hole and somehow the ice did not break again and I got out. Time stands still and you just do what you can. I remember feeling like I was watching myself. Very glad you made it - your images are an inspiration !

sarge
 
Gary, I also choose to hunt only with my best partner who happens to be a yellow lab and probably would have done the same thing. Glad it all turned out for both of you. We have to be careful out there!!!
 
Gary,

That was a great lesson and story too.

Your photos were great then, and still great in more recent hunts.


I had a buddy fall in the ice with a friend and a dog on a deep pond. Apparently the dog damned nearly drowned them both trying to climb up and my buddy was able to push off the bottom and plunge his kabar into the ice on the edge and pull himself up about a foot at a time, then stab the ice again, and pull another foot, over and over.

Chills me to the core thinking about it.

I believe that when it is my time to go, ( if I have to go) Leaving in an effort to save someone I love (man or beast) would be a noble and valiant way to leave this place.

Glad it wasn't your time, or that great dog of yours....
 
You have many things to be thankful for Gary!!
I too love hunting with just my dog. I have had simular scares and there are places where I
won't hunt when ice is present. I'm sure you now keep your whistle readily available. The other
thing I do is carry one of those 21' decoy retrieving hooks when hunting flowing water or light ice.
I've never used it for any of my dogs but after my first crawl on the ice I feel better with it along.
I hunt solo 90% of the time but never hunt without a companion,
John
 
Glad to hear it ended well. I feel the same about my girl and would have done the same. Your pics always amaze me. Thanks for taking the time to post them, Kevin
 
I can totally relate to that story Gary. I primarily hunt alone with my retriever and prefer it, though I do cherish the days I get out with my father, brother and a couple of close friends. My pup means the world to me and I'm certain I would've done the same thing. I'm still shuddering from a close call grouse hunting this year while my pup was doing his thing flushing a spruce grouse (so I thought) when I realized he was about to stick his head in a lynx trap. He can be stubborn at times but for once he listened immediately to the recall yell - probably because he sensed the urgency in my voice.

Really glad everything worked out for you. BTW, I really enjoy your posts and pictures!
 
great story and nice ending but hunting with a dog your never hunting alone, and the bond between the hunter and dog is so great, that the hunter will risk his life often to save his companion but I wonder the wisdom of risking your life......I know it is a very tough choice but I am sure you have many others to consider as well
 
Back
Top