***i'm going to preface EVERYTHING i post with I'VE NEVER HUNTED WITH CATFISH, so I can NOT speak from personal experience. and, i wouldn't know him if he stepped in my office right now...***
having said that, catfish (or the operation tallahatchie hunts) sponsors a mississippi duck board i'm a long time member of and they post up weekly/daily "updates" on their killing....they seem to do really well as far as numbers go and in the 2 or 3 years they've sponsored the forum, I've never seen anyone get on the board and verbally "thrash" the outfit for a shoddy job which, by my estimation, is saying something considering i've yet to see anyone that's on the web not get publically flamed for what others perceive as a bad hunting experience...just part of it i suppose.
I don't know whether or not they hunt true "timber" or old dead lakes off the river, not that it really matters when teh birds are down, BUT it could matter for YOUR experience. truth of the matter there's not much opportunity for "true" timber hunting down here anymore - rich man's game - even for the guide services, though they are there...
not sure this is a great help but i did want to say that from what I see/read, catfish and the flautt's do a good job...
justin