James Woods
Active member
Somewhat belately I thought I would weigh in. I grew up on the North Shore of Long Island about 60 miles from NYC. I lived less than a mile from an 11k acre salt marsh, and within 20 miles of numerous other salt marshes. In the early sixties, I prowled all those marshes, clamming, fishing, eeling and getting to know the old timers who had fished and hunted those marshes since the 20s ("Dollars to donuts in a NWester, the birds will pile in behind the Smith Place"-a memorable quote from one old timer.) I hunted my home salt marsh from the early sixties until 1985. Between 1963 and 1975 I was in that marsh 3 times a week during the gunning season(more during college vacation), less so in the years after, but several times a season. Our bags were black ducks, on rare occasion a widgeon and, of course mallards in the salt marsh. On the channels we shot shellpeckers, buffies, a few broadiebeeks, and on occasion a redhead or can (no cans or redheads for me!). Geese were also rare. This was the experience of the old timers as well dating back many years. Now my friends are routinely killing gadwalls. We never saw gadwalls and no anecdotal oral history from the old timers indicates that they shot such birds either. Between 80-84, I was living in Port Jefferson, not far from my old home, and we had several severe winters like this winter, and I began seeing gadwalls in Scott's Cove in Setauket harbor. First year, a dozen maybe, then in succeeding years up to 1984 about 60. I can only think that they expanded around to the other nearby salt marshes. I know nothing about the feeding habits of gadwalls, but they seemed quite happy feeding in the mudflats of Setauket Harbor.