Rick, I'm sure you'll be happy with your lab, and it's definitely the safer choice if you primarily hunt waterfowl.
But you asked about a springers, and pinged my memory.
The Springer we had when I was a kid, Joshua, was perhaps the best water dog I ever saw. His swim "training" came at about 4 months when he chased a poorly thrown stick onto thin ice and broke through. I'd thrown the stick, and figured he was a goner. (I was about 11.) He not only survived--as soon as he reached shore he ran back out onto the ice to do it all over again. The stick was still out there--and it must be retrieved! He once chased a loon over the horizon on a 10 mile wide lake. We had to chase him down in a boat. I watched him spend the better of an hour in February trying to retrieve a lobster trap buoy that was 25 yards off the beach. He got the buoy in his mouth and wouldn't let go. I bet he did the equivalent of 2 miles of swimming in tethered circles around that pot. He used to retrieve rocks off the bottom in up to 3 feet of water. We didn't duck hunt then, so he may have missed his chance to shine.
Comments above about the coat (ask my sister about the great bubblegum caper of 1981), independent spirit, and willingness to ignore the trainer are spot on. And he'd pick a fight with anyone. I once got a call from a neighbor who complained he'd attacked her pair of dogs--a Great Dane and a BIG lab. From the sound of things after I put my father on the phone, Joshua won that fight.
But he was an awfully sweet dog, and made his last retrieve (a raquetball) on his way into the vet's office to be put down with liver tumors. He was not a favorite at the vet's--to put it mildly he was not a model patient. But even the receptionist who preferred cats and poodles cried when he scrambled under her desk after that ball.