NDR - House was vandalized again - Restorative Justice program

Mark W

Well-known member
Saturday before Father's day, my son was golfing and returned home around 8:45. He and a couple of buddies came inside and had some pizza. Garage door was closed about 9:30 pm.

Next morning (Father's Day) I walked into the garage to put our clubs in the vehicle to play golf with my son only to find them not in their usual place. It was at this time I realized the clubs had been stolen.

To say this was upsetting is a vast understatement. This is the 4th time we have been vandalized in the past 4 years or so. We do not live in a place where one would expect crime to be a problem. My son is on the high School golf team and plays golf everyday to get better for next year. Now he is without clubs. If you are a golfer, you will not be surprised to learn that between two sets of clubs, over $6,000 was stolen from my that evening not to mention the time and anguish it has caused my family since.

I sent a list of exactly what was stolen to all the local outlets where clubs like this could possibly be exchanged for cash. I also alerted the neighborhood about this theft via our home owner association alert system.

Thursday I get a call from the local police saying that a kid had attempted to sell one set of clubs to a nearby Play it Again sports store. The alert employee immediately recognized the clubs and went in the back room and called the police who came and intervened. Clubs were returned to my police department and I picked up the clubs that afternoon. Still missing one set of clubs.

That evening, a neighbor was on a walk and noticed a black car parked outside my house with 2 kids in it. It should be mentioned that the night of the theft, some neighbor kids saw a black car pull up our street, turn its headlights off and park in front of our house. This neighbor, brave soul that he is, went up to the kids and asked if they needed any help. Kids said they were just waiting for a friend. When the neighbor asked what the name of their friend was, the ids didn't know and peeled off. Neighbor got a partial license plate number. Cops were called again. I was now wondering if these kids were coming back to do harm as they had been caught earlier. My first thought was wondering if I needed to get my shotgun out of the basement. My family was that worried.

Friday while at work, I get a frantic call from my 15 year old son saying that cops were all over outside. As he was telling me this, a cop came to the door. Seems that my golf clubs had suddenly appeared outside the neighbors garage. Not 15 minutes earlier my son had mowed that area and had not seen any clubs. I came home to find the cops and my clubs gone. A call to the police department to find out what was happening went unanswered at this time.

I get a call later that day saying that my set of clubs had been recovered. Guess the kids came back to return my clubs after realizing how much trouble they were in. They watched my son mow the yard and when he went into the back, they put my clubs next to a neighbors garage. Two of the kids wanted to return my set of clubs to me in person and say how sorry they were for all the trouble they caused. One kid said that they would probably have the crap beat out of them by me if they went this route. Smart kid and at least one good decision was made.

Police had interviewed two of the four sets of parents prior to me getting a call. The cop said he had never heard parents who were as upset as these were. He jokingly said he thought he might be returning to a dead body call in a couple of hours.

To make a really long story short, 4 kids were involved. 3 minors and one 18 year old. None had been in trouble prior to this but had admitted to stealing stuff out of garages prior to stealing from me. They just hadn't been caught.

The kids have not been arrested nor charged with any crimes at this time though a written confession is in the possession of the police. The crime pending is first degree felony burglery or felony theft I can't recall which one but it is a serious offense.

I was asked what I want to do as I have a choice. The cops can go and charge the kids with the felony, or, if I want I can participate in a program called Restorative Justice. I guess this allows me a chance to speak to the kids and tell them what this has done to me and my family both financially and psychologically. I also get to chose the punishment I think is appropriate. If the kids then do as I wish, they do not get a felony charge on their record.

According to the cop who has been working with juveniles and juvenile crime for 18 years, he believes 3 of the 4 kids are scared stiff and the parents extremely upset and disappointed. He believes that if given a second chance, these kids will not be repeat offenders. The 4th kid he is fairly certain will also not offend again but is not completely sure.

When I was younger, I made mistakes and was given a second chance. It was from these mistakes I made in my life that turned me around. I never did anything as bad as what these kids have done but I was no angel either. I believe these kids deserve that chance and am going to participate in this program Thursday evening. My decision, and thus the note, is what would you ask in return for this second chance?

All my stuff has not been returned to me from the golf clubs. I am asking for the money to replace what is missing. This amounts to about $600. I am also asking to be refunded for the pizza party I threw for the staff of the play it again store and the gift card purchased for the kid who actually called the police. Because of this last theft, we are installing motion activated lights, a video surveillance camera and a couple of security signs. My opinion, that is different than my wifes, is that this too should be put on the financial reimbursement restitution request. I do not know what this will cost but expect it to be well north of $500.

I am also requesting a letter of apology be written to my family, the Woodbury Police, and the Play it Again sports store. I don't ever want to see these kids on my street again, nor do I want them to ever discuss any of this with their friends. It is very likely my son knows the three minors and I want no harm to come his way after all this is settled. The detective suggested I assign 20 - 40 hours of community service time to each of the criminals and require them to serve this time individually, not together. I get to chose the service they are to complete.

What else would you do? What would you say to these kids when you meet them and their parents Thursday? What would be a fitting punishment for what these 4 kids have put my family through?

As always, thanks for listening and thanks for all suggestions.

Mark W
 
Mark
I'll bet the 18 year old was the ring leader and should be charged with a felony. The other scared 3 should have learned their lesson and let that be their punishment. Pushing for repayment can cause some real problems. Better to accept the loss. My two cents.
wis boz
 
Felony convictions last a long time on your record. Have the 18 yr old do service with the DNR, give him some time with something that could change his outlook on life.
 
Felony convictions last a long time on your record. Have the 18 yr old do service with the DNR, give him some time with something that could change his outlook on life.
.
.
.
an outside job - where there are plenty of ticks and chiggars!
Re-imbursement of items missing for sure... but in this day and age, the cost of a home security system is almost a given - regardless of the type of community that you live in.
 
Meet with the families and the kids. Go from there with the punishment. 20 - 40 hours community service is not much. Their summer serving instead of out playing with their buddies is what should happen. A little humility goes a long way. They tried to ruin your summer, interrupt theirs. The parents should bear some of the problem.
The felony will stay with them for a long time. College, job apps, military and buying a gun. Have the judge explain it to them and their parents. 4473 asks if you have had a felony that Could have given you a year in jail.
 
Mark,
First off, you were not vandalized........you were ROBBED. These kids didn't egg your house, toilet paper the tree in front of your house or graffiti the side of your garage............they ROBBED you.

If these guys were a couple of years older there wouldn't be any discussion - they would be in jail. The fact that they are being offered a second chance is huge and they should know that. Certainly have whatever talk that will make you feel better with them and their parents. Hopefully it will impress upon them what the emotional impact is of stealing from others. It is likely that their parents are, already, punishing them severely - disappointment and disapproval are powerful emotions for young people

IMO, punishment beyond restitution should be left up to the juvenal justice professional. If you are in charge of the punishment your emotions are going to get in the way and you will likely pick something that may not be appropriate. Ask for the right to approve what they pick but let someone else pick the punishment.

When it comes to restitution I believe you should be made whole, kind of like insurance. Whatever is still missing or stuff that was broken or damaged in any way needs to be made right. Funding a complete security system is not one of those things - that's your emotional response taking over.

Lastly, think about this. If they were your kids and you knew this was a one time event and they really are good people, eventually, after all the punishment and restitution is done, you would forgive them and allow them to move on without judgement.
 
I would want repayment for sure. I am with you as giving a second chance. I know a guy who got in trouble as a young man and got the felony. He is 32 now with a wife and 2 kids. He never reoffeneded and this still gives him trouble to this day. Everyone makes mistakes some big and some small. Most deserves a 2nd chance and a swift kick.

As far as punishment do they have a scared straight program where they send the kids to jail for a day. Also see if they have road side trash clean up for connunity service. My friend did this and he said it embarrassed him to wear that orange vest and clean up trash on the highway where cars driving by ccould see him.

Good luck on thurs.
 
Forgot a couple of items. We were in the house, not 20 feet away from where these kids had to go and steal the clubs. Unnerving to say the least. Also, we have a monitored security system and have for many years. Unfortunately, it does not cover the garage. Since the 3 previous crimes occurred in our driveway with vehicles parked there, motion lights sound like an added protection.

How about this sign? Too provocative maybe? Or another one that says "We don't call 911".

View attachment sign.jpg

Thanks for the comments

Mark W
 
How about this sign? Too provocative maybe? Or another one that says "We don't call 911".



Thanks for the comments

Mark W

If you are going the yard sign route, this is my favorite:

neighbor1.jpg

 
What stuck with me throughout this whole thread is that they had robbed other homes, and yours more than once. I dont agree with many of the responces. They only feel bad because they got caught. Im guessing the 18 year old is a senoir in HS or just got out making the others right behind him. I dont feel that he was the ring leader. There isnt a ring leader when kids are that age. If peer pressure was the case they wouldnt have done it more than once, maybe twice. Those young men are old enough to know that what they did time and time again was wrong. They stole from you and others for personal gain because they are lazy. Worthless. Hand it too them. I'd give them the felonies, or hold the parents just as responsible. Let those parents feel some heat too and I guarantee they wont do it again. If they know your son and that he plays golf, he was intentionally targeted.
 
I love mercy. My eternity depends on it. I love to give mercy. When I was broken into I beat the man only I was sure he was no longer a threat to my family (first mercy). For a split second I was going to kill him and I did not (second mercy) I let him accept the plea deal with the state( 3rd mercy). I was glad he was in jail (mercy over).
I have a friend that is almost 50 years old that is still paying the price of a felony when he was 18. It is sad but he has raised 4 kids that understand very well that their action will have lifelong consequenses. My friend has a good job, owns a home and has a great family. Who knows where this man may have ended up had he been spared the felony. By doing so the justise system may have kicked the can down the road till he was a super felon. No one knows for sure. One thing I do know for sure is that he has survived it.
I would let them the kids take the felony rap. It may save their life...and the life of others.
 
How about letting the justice system do their job. But aside from that...

If you really want them to understand Biblical mercy, how about asking them each individually with their dad (assuming he is in the picture) to go hunting or fishing with you as your guest. Invite the kids (individually again) to go with you to watch your son play golf.

Yes, really! befriend them.
"...as we forgive those who trespass against us..."
 
Face to face apologies is what i would want and expect. Years ago while working as a commerical construction super in Livonia I had all of our tools stolen by a young man who was hooked on free basing. long story short the brother law paid for all the tools and this young man after he came down/ran out of money wanted to come back to work. I told him he had to go man to man on that site look them in the eye , and apologize. It took most of the morning but it humbled him. I would like to think it made a difference.


I worked in the prison system for 5 years . putting kids in the system is only going to make them better/violent adult criminals.
 
Mark, you sure live one interesting life.

Here is my take, I think this is placing too much of a burden on you: Did you give them to little or too much punishment? What if they re-offend, is it then your fault? If it's too much of a punishment, are they going to want retribution? All of these questions are going to be on your mind going forward, and what do you get out of it? A few bucks back and "Closour", ain't worth it, let the system handle it and move on.

I have a friend who used to be a professional thief. Didn't stop until he was caught a spent some time in jail. He will tell you it was the best thing that could have happened to him, he also started small and worked his way up.

Andrew
 
Mark,

that is quite the story and I am sure glad no one was hurt!!!

Only you can decide...but since you asked I guess my inital thoughts on this matter are this is not their first time...yah they may be scared and all that, but honestly, how are you and your family feeling about being violated? my house has been robbed 2 times in the last 5 years (garage/cars) etc. and honestly, it is terrifying for many. I guess I have seen these things go both ways, good and bad, but when it comes down to it, how do you feel personally about it? I asked my bro in law who is a judge and his opinion for what it is worth is that the law/jail often does NOT rehabilitate people with any great measure of success....

there was a book written about the rehabiliative justice, my kid brought it home a few years back, pretty good. Kids had to go to alaska and live for a year off the land with minimal assistance. dang...what was that books name.

anyhow, best of luck, I agree on the motion sensors/camera deals. The big thing is staying in touch with neighbors so they can all watch out for each other.
 
Mark,

Did they have easy access? Was the garage unlocked?

Locks keep the honest people honest.

Ron


son came home from the golf coarse at 8:45 pm and opened the garage door. He and his buddies had pizza. Wife closed the door at 9:30pm. Clubs cannot be seen from the street. They had to either know what was in there from previous scouting, could have followed my son home from the coarse, or just dumb luck were driving round and saw our door open for those 45 minutes. I'll find out Thursday.

Mark W
 
Mark,

First I know the anguish and uneasiness your family is going through now. I have had a few items taken from my backyard in the past 2 years and its nerveracking thinking about how long they were watching you. Second, after thinking about this for awhile I really cant wrap my head around a felony charge. Imagine one of your children gets in with the wrong crowd and makes a bad decision and from there on out is unable to ever purchase a firearm among a list of many other things.

I think there is a medium between the extreme (felony) and no punishment. If they are repeat offenders there must be something else done besides 40 hours of community service. Also make it known how big of a break you are really giving them. Lay it out what they could miss out on in life if they got a felony. I dont think federal aid for school is granted, no firearms, hard to get a job, etc.

I messed up real bad when I was late in high school, nothing of a felony sorts, but I was nearly kicked out of high school. Seeing how I woke up after that and how fortunate I have been in college makes me really think how bad it would have been had I gotten kicked out and gotten the whole book thrown at me.

I hope you you give it to them just enough to realize how bad they messed up but not as to much to ruin their young lives. Good luck!
 
Back
Top