The first year we had one when nobody else did, and it was the most incredible thing I have ever seen. The next year everyone had one. You'd occasionally see a 'battery' duck, but as often as not ducks would hook but not finish. When arkie outlawed them i was relived, it was one less thing to fool with, and if nobody had one, then the bleacher seats went back to being bleacher seats, and the good spots killed birds like they always had. When arkie backed off it, and allowed them, welp, there ya go. Like most things duck related, rarely does something work every single day. So they are a varible like everything else... but when ducks are 'frantic' trying to feed before a freeze, or after a thaw, they are still deadly. 75% of the time they arent anything but trouble. But that 25% of the time, the shot is over the top of the dang thing....
Tradtion means different to a lot of differnet people. I think its more in your hart and your actions than your equipement personally. Given my druthers, they'd go back to being outlawed, so we could have something to gripe about (dude was right above about it being a great thing to aruge about, and thats as duck hunting tradation is there is!). travis