Very nice! Congratulations!
I agree, since it is the catalyst component that drives the reaction for urethane foams, determining expansion rate, bubble size and consequent density, you're likely getting an end-product that is denser than fresh 4lb foam would generate.
IF you want to fill-in the decoy bases to minimize adhesion of "marsh stuff" ( Aufwuchs, or attached community is the limnologic term), flat black Rust-Oleum applied at three to four coats will work well.