Last week I was out boating in freezing temps and took along a pair of ski gloves made by The North Face.  They are Goretex and have a very generous tall cuff that draws tight over your coat if you want.  I have used them for several years when the weather gets really frosty.  They are outstanding for running the boat and setting and picking up decoys.  I picked up and wrapped 70 or so decoys and my hands never got damp on the inside.  The gloves were covered in ice but my hands were warm.  I have neoprene gloves, and many other "waterproof" hunting gloves but nothing has ever come close to those old ski gloves.  Then again they are probably the most expensive gloves I have ever seen.  LOL  I also wear them when I run the snowblower, shovel the drive and on those rare occasions that I ski.  They go on late season and early season canoe trips as well, since you never know when it will start to snow.  I am going out in the boat again tomorrow morning and the weatherman says it will be well below freezing.  I will have my trusty ski gloves with me again.  
I have hunted with folks wearing the "fisherman" style PVC gloves.  I am not sure if they were Atlas but the bulk and stiffness of the gloves put me off.